Observations from Executive Search: The Job Market Isn't One Job Market
As I was finishing last month's Blog, two stories appeared in the business news. One concerned significant job cuts coming at Amazon. Another suggested that layoffs might be coming at 3M.
Neither story was particularly encouraging. But then I looked at our firm's active executive searches and the opportunities we were discussing with prospective clients. The picture was remarkably different.
- Layoffs at Amazon and 3M make national headlines. Yet hundreds of smaller companies quietly adding employees rarely receive the same attention. Are we allowing the headlines to define an economy they only partially represent?
Two things are happening at once. Some major employers are cutting jobs while other companies are having difficulty finding the talent they need. The explanation is relatively simple: The job market isn't one job market.
My Morning Routine
I have written before about my morning routine. This routine is repeated weekdays, weekends and even when I am on vacation. I check Facebook (checking for birthdays, etc.); I look at varying economic indicators and then review three news sources. This is all done in 20 minutes.
What Is Executive Search Telling Us About The Economy
Activity in the Executive Search industry can provide an interesting window into the health of the economy. There are other indicators I watch . . . . . some are more data driven and predictive than others:
- Shipping Containers – the number of containers moving at any given time are an indicator of economic strength. (Interestingly, September volume at the Port of Los Angeles rose 18.1% year over year.)
- Trucking Tonnage – September trucking tonnage rose 0.8% from August but was unchanged from a year earlier. Freight activity is holding up, but it isn't showing particularly strong growth.
- Men’s Underwear – often associated with former Federal Reserve Chair Alan Greenspan, the theory is that men postpone buying replacement underwear when finances become tight. The logic is entertaining, but evidence that underwear sales reliably predict recessions is weak. Call it ‘currently inconclusive’.
I recently attended a meeting with a peer group of executive search firm owners from around the country. Collectively, we work across numerous industries, functions and geographic markets.
One of the interesting observations from our meeting was that we are all relatively busy. Despite the headlines about layoffs and economic uncertainty, companies are continuing to invest in hiring leadership talent.
And during our Monday meeting alone (November 2nd), I received four separate inquiries about potential executive searches for our firm.
Does that mean every company is going to search? Of course not. But it certainly suggests that the employment picture is more complicated than the headlines might lead us to believe.
Who Is Creating Jobs?
When we think about America's economy, we often think about the Fortune 500 – the corporate giants that dominate the business headlines. Yet according to the U.S. Small Business Administration, small businesses accounted for 61% of America's net new jobs between 1995 and 2024.
- The companies making the biggest headlines aren't necessarily the companies creating the most jobs.
Research from the U.S. Census Bureau suggests that the age of a company may be more important than its size in explaining job creation. Startups and young businesses contribute disproportionately to new employment.
Perhaps we should spend a little less time watching the Fortune 500 and a little more time paying attention to the smaller companies. Perhaps the problem isn't the job market itself – it could be how we measure it, how the numbers are reported, and how we interpret what we're being told.
Back To My Morning Routine – The Numbers
The unemployment numbers tell us what is happening in aggregate. Today, here is where we are:
- National – 4.1% (October, 2026 – reported on November 6th)
- State of Minnesota – 4.5% (September, 2026)
- Minneapolis/St. Paul/Bloomington – 4.5% (September, 2026)
- 4-year degree or higher (and age 25 and older) – 2.6% (October, 2026 – reported on November 6th)
These numbers are historically positive. Please note – there is no precise definition of ‘full employment’. In the early 1960s, President Kennedy's chief economic adviser, Walter Heller, considered 4% unemployment a reasonable benchmark for full employment. More than 50 years later, during the Obama administration, economists at the Federal Reserve generally viewed unemployment of approximately 5% as consistent with a fully functioning labor market.
But We Can’t Find People And People Can’t Find Companies
Imagine two companies in the same city.
- One is a manufacturer that has stopped hiring, eliminated positions, and is concerned about declining orders.
- The other is a growing healthcare organization that cannot find enough qualified people to fill its leadership positions.
Both companies operate in the same economy. Both contribute to the same national employment statistics. They are experiencing two entirely different job markets.
Let’s Look At The Availability Of Talent From Different Lenses
A CEO may see increasing unemployment and assume recruiting will become easier. An HR executive may still struggle to find qualified candidates for specialized positions. A professional who has been unemployed for several months may wonder where all the jobs have gone. And someone who is happily employed may receive multiple inquiries about new career opportunities.
All four are looking at the same economy. But they are experiencing very different job markets. We frequently hear references to "the job market" as though it were one enormous marketplace where employers and candidates operate under the same conditions.
- But there is no single job market.
There are markets for accountants, engineers, sales executives, manufacturing leaders, healthcare professionals, and thousands of other occupations. There are markets influenced by geography, industry, company size, and required years of experience. And while one employer may be eliminating positions, another may be struggling to find the people necessary to support its growth. The national statistics are important. But they don't always tell us what's happening in our own backyard.
Two Closing Thoughts
- For employers, the lesson is to understand the talent market in which you are actually competing. A rising unemployment rate doesn't necessarily mean the people you need are readily available. And the best candidates aren't necessarily looking for another job.
- For job seekers, the lesson is equally important. A company announcing layoffs may make headlines, but there are other employers, industries and geographic markets where opportunities continue to exist. Finding them may require looking beyond the obvious.
There are markets for accountants, engineers, sales executives, manufacturing leaders, healthcare professionals, and thousands of other occupations. There are markets influenced by geography, industry, company size, and required years of experience. And while one employer may be eliminating positions, another may be struggling to find the people necessary to support its growth. The national statistics are important. But they don't always tell us what's happening in our own backyard.
Two Closing Thoughts
The national unemployment rate is an important economic measure. But it is an average. It doesn't tell the entire story.
So, the next time someone tells you the job market is good – or that the job market is terrible – perhaps the appropriate response is a simple question:
Good or bad for whom?
As always, I welcome your thoughts and reactions. Everyone has their own perspective on the job market, and often their own personal story. I'd enjoy hearing yours.
David Magy
Principal & Co-Founder
David Magy, a thought leader in executive search and leadership, is a Principal with Abeln, Magy, Underberg & Associates, a nationally recognized retained executive search firm. For 30 years, he has partnered with organizations across North America to recruit executive and senior-level leaders, advise on leadership strategy, and help build high-performing teams. As a frequent speaker and writer on executive search, leadership, market trends, and the future of work, David is passionate about helping organizations and executives make informed, long-term decisions that create lasting success.
View David on LinkedIn